Best Toys for Aggressive Chewing Dogs of 2023 Complete Reviews with Comparisons

***SmartlyPet is supported by readers. If you click one of my links, I may earn commissions. I am also participant in the Amazon affiliate program and I will also make a commission from qualifying purchases. Thank you***

Do you have a dog that demolishes all of its toys? It’s a problem with many dogs, and buying toys for them becomes a challenge. However, there are a few toys that can stand up to even the most aggressive chewers. Let’s get to it and help you find the best toys for aggressive chewing dogs.

KONG – Extreme Dog Toy – Toughest Natural Rubber

Kong is a well-known brand in the world of dog toys due to the toughness of their products. When it comes to the toughest brand of dog toys, there is likely nothing stronger than something from Kong.

Review

The KONG 41940 Extreme Dog Toy comes in 5 different sizes, so you should be able to find the right size for your dog. This toy is made out of the so-called extreme rubber, which is about as durable as it gets. We think it is worth noting that this toy is made in the USA.

If you have a massive dog with powerful jaws that loves to chew, it might eventually wear the KONG 41940 Extreme Dog Toy down, but other than that, it should last more or less forever. It is super tough.

This toy is also available in different rubber types, mainly softer types for puppies and aging dogs. Therefore, this dog toy is suitable for all sizes and all ages of dogs.

Although eating rubber probably isn’t the best, this dog toy is made out of safe materials. If your dog swallows a couple chunks, it really shouldn’t be a big deal. Moreover, the KONG 41940 Extreme Dog Toy is ideal for dental hygiene because chewing on it should help remove plaque and tartar.

To help make things a bit more fun, this toy allows you to smear peanut butter and other treats into the hollow opening, and that’s something that will keep your dog occupied. To clean it off, simply stick it in the dishwasher.

Pros

  • Superior durability
  • Various sizes
  • Can put treats inside
  • Easy to clean
  • Good for dental hygiene
  • Made in the USA

Cons

  • The very strong rubber smell
  • Very large and powerful dogs will eventually chew through it

Wobble Wag Giggle Ball, Interactive Dog Toy

This ball from Wobble Wag Giggle is exceptionally durable and interactive; it makes funny noises when moved around. Dogs will have lots of fun playing with this ball.

Review

The Wobble Wag Giggle Ball is made of very tough rubber, so it should be able to withstand months of chewing, especially when small and medium-size dogs are in question. That said, even the toughest of toys will only last so long if you have a giant and powerful dog. However, this is one of the tougher toys when it comes down to it, as it is made out of a very tough and solid rubber.

What makes the Wobble Wag Giggle Ball so great for dogs are its several noisemakers. When the ball is rolled around, chewed on, or picked up, it makes different noises. This will keep dogs entertained. There are several holes or “clutch pockets” that allow your dog to easily pick it up.

The Wobble Wag Giggle Ball is made of rubber, so you can just wash it off in the sink when it gets dirty.

Pros

  • Very durable
  • Makes noise
  • Good for the teeth
  • Easy to pick up
  • Ideal for small and medium-size dogs
  • Easy to wash

Cons

  • Large and powerful dogs may be able to chew through it
  • Noisemakers may degrade after prolonged use

Goughnuts Large Dog Pull Toy

If you need a tough toy for a very large and destructive dog that loves to chew, this Goughnuts Large Dog Pull Toy is another excellent option to consider. However, it is expensive, costing over $50 after tax. But that said, it’s also one of the toughest chew toys at this time.

Review

The Goughnuts Large Dog Pull Toy comes in the shape of a figure 8  − 2 loops joined in the middle. This is good for multiple dogs, as 2 dogs can play tug of war with it, and you can also play tug with your dog.

Although the Goughnuts Large Dog Pull Toy is not 100% indestructible, it is made out of some of the toughest, densest, and most pliable rubber. It will take a large and powerful dog at least several weeks to put a dent in it.

If you have a small or medium-size dog, this toy should last for months or even years. It’s made with the same rubber polymers used for aircraft materials.

Also, it is made in the USA. Now, the cool part here is that the Goughnuts Large Dog Pull Toy is guaranteed for life. If your dog breaks it in any way, it will be replaced free of cost. So, although it costs $50, it’s a lifetime investment, and we think it is well worth the price.

The Goughnuts Large Dog Pull Toy is also great for dental hygiene. In case your dog drops it in a puddle, in a lake, or into the water, no worries, because it even floats. The rubber is also food grade, so if your dog swallows a piece, it’s no big deal. Finally, cleaning is as easy as washing it in the sink.

Pros

  • Extremely durable
  • Suitable for dogs of all sizes
  • Made in the USA
  • Food-grade rubber
  • Floats on water
  • Lifetime guarantee
  • Easy to clean

Cons

  • Expensive

KONG – Flyer Frisbee

This is another great toy for dogs that like to chew and for dogs that love playing fetch. It is a frisbee, so it’s not exactly designed for extreme chewing, but that said, it is still made of tough materials.

Review

Although the Kong Flyer Frisbee is not designed for heavy chewers, it is a frisbee that you play fetch with. If you keep your dog busy playing fetch, they really won’t get the opportunity to chew on it very much. It’s the kind of interactive toy that you play with, and then once you are done with your fetch session, you take it from your dog and put it away.

That said, the Kong Flyer Frisbee is made out of very tough rubber, so if your dog does happen to chew heavily, it should still last for quite some time. However, a very large and powerful dog can wear it down with extensive chewing. This frisbee is super flexible and pliable, so it should withstand being punctured by teeth.

We would like to mention that the Kong Flyer Frisbee is made in the USA. Moreover, thanks to the fact that it is made of rubber, it is also very easy to clean under the kitchen yap or with a hose. Finally, the Kong Flyer Frisbee comes with a thin rim and various textured grooves, making it easy to pick up, particularly for smaller dogs.

Pros

  • Good for all sizes
  • Great for playing fetch
  • Fairly durable
  • Easy to pick up
  • Easy to clean
  • Reasonable price
  • Made in the USA

Cons

  • Not designed for constant chewing

Durable Wishbone Dog Chew Toy for Aggressive Chewers

Something like this Benebone Wishbone Durable Dog Chew Toy is always an excellent option to consider if you have an aggressive chewer and you want to ensure that your dog’s dental hygiene is top-notch.

Review

What is really nice about the Benebone Wishbone Durable Dog Chew Toy is that it tastes like bacon. Only 100% real and naturally sourced bacon was used, so not only will it taste fantastic for your dog, but it is also totally safe.

The Benebone Wishbone Durable Dog Chew Toy is made of super-tough rubber, tougher than most other dog toys. It can withstand very heavy chewing for a long time, even from relatively large dogs. However, of course, it is not 100% indestructible. Once it starts to deteriorate, it will need to be replaced.

However, the main point of the Benebone Wishbone Durable Dog Chew Toy is dental hygiene, so even if your dog does manage to chew it to shreds, at least it is good for their teeth. Just like many of the other toys we reviewed, it is also made in the USA.

Something your dog may enjoy about the Benebone Wishbone Durable Dog Chew Toy is that it is shaped like a wishbone, making it very easy for dogs to pick up and hold with their paws while they gnaw on it.

Pros

  • Superior durability
  • Made in the USA
  • Tastes like bacon – real bacon
  • Great for dental hygiene
  • Easy to wash
  • Reasonable price
  • Ideal for all dog sizes

Cons

  • Not edible – will need periodic replacement
  • Some dogs seem to not like the flavor

Buyer’s Guide

Before you go shopping, let’s first consider what you should be looking for when buying durable dog toys.

Material

The only material that is suitable for chew toys for heavy chewers is rubber. The higher quality the rubber, the better. Rubber is strong enough to resist chewing, yet also pliable, so it won’t hurt your dog’s teeth.

Dog’s Age

Remember that old dogs and puppies should not be given very solid toys to chew on, as it can hurt their teeth. Be sure to consider the age and condition of your dog when choosing a chew toy.

Dog’s Size

The bigger and more powerful the dog, the bigger and tougher the toy needs to be. Also, keep in mind that toys designed for small breeds should not be given to large breeds, as there is a choking risk.

Texture

A toy with some texture will make it easier to pick up and hold onto. Dogs seem to love toys with texture.

Safety

Always make sure that the toy is made of materials that are nontoxic. Chances are almost 100% that your dog will swallow a piece of the toy at some point, so it does need to be safe in this sense.

FAQ

What is the Best Material for a Chew Toy?

The only material that you should be going for when it comes to chew toys is rubber.

What if My Dog Swallows Chunks of its Toys?

If your dog swallows some chunks, and the toy is nontoxic, keep an eye out for the chunks when your dog defecates. If you notice that no toy chunks are coming out, but your dog has clearly swallowed the chunks, then you will need to go see a vet.

Are Some Toys Dangerous?

Yes, hard plastic chew toys are not suitable for a dog’s teeth and can lead to blockages when swallowed. The long, frayed ends of rope toys can pose choking hazards and intestinal problems when chewed apart. Once again, solid rubber is the way to go.

Conclusion

The toughest toy for your dog is the KONG 41940 Extreme Dog Toy. When it comes down to it, Kong toys are the toughest at this time.